Roofing

Best Roofing Shingles: Brands Compared by Real Roofers

date posted

11/03/26

read time

7 Mins

Malarkey Highlander-Best-Roofing-Shingles

Originally published October 1, 2021. Updated November 3, 2026.

Among the roofers we surveyed, Malarkey was the most common pick for best roofing shingle, with Atlas Pinnacle, Owens Corning Duration and GAF Timberline close behind. Malarkey fans point to durability and its wide nailing strip; Atlas fans point to the warranty.

Hook Agency does not have deals with any shingle manufacturer. We looked at major publications, sat through demos from top brands, and asked working roofers which shingle they trust most.

Here is what contractors believe is the best shingle on the market, in their own words.

Here’s a quick rundown of how top roofing shingle brands, stack up amongst the pack:

  • GAF calls itself North America’s largest roofing manufacturer and was founded in 1886. It has one of the widest product lines.
  • Owens Corning is another extremely large manufacturer, and a long-time Fortune 500 company, but size does not necessarily mean best. (Owens Corning often gets classed as an Affordable winner)
  • Certainteed is called a high-end brand
  • Malarkey was the top pick among the roofers we surveyed (see their comments below).
  • TAMKO and IKO are usually positioned as budget options, and some of the roofers we surveyed rank them lower.

Roofers Share Why They Love Certain Shingles

What are the Best Roofing Shingles?

In our survey, Malarkey came up more than any other brand, followed by Atlas and Owens Corning Duration. Published rankings do not agree on one winner: RoofOnline notes CertainTeed may have the best reputation among the largest makers, while other lists favor GAF Timberline HDZ. The right answer depends on your climate, budget and the warranty your installer can offer.

What Real Roofers Say About the Best Shingle Brands

Love the Malarkey shingles

They hold up so well. We can look at neighborhoods houses done with other brands at the same time in 2013. The malarkey looks 5 years newer. That speaks for itself.

Satirah Moore, Watchdog Roofing

Malarkey hands down, super large nail strip

Malarkey hands down, super large nail strip outperforms every other shingle in durability especially the IR ones. Granules embedded vs laid on top and the sealants… where they lay there for good and the sealants are also highly elastic which is great for long term durability. No competition

Travis Wolfbauer, roofer

Atlas, for their warranty

Great rep, awesome warranty just need to use 4 of there products, don’t have to upsell a better warranty. Had one color issue which I asked for 2 slopes to be replaced and Atlas came back and said we will pay 100 percent cost for roof to be tore off and replaced.

Carson Feiner, Feiner Construction

Atlas Pinnacle HP

In its time ELK had the best laminate money could buy. Then GAF bought them and systematically ruined the shingle and the company. Today, the Atlas Pinnacle HP with Scotchgard Protector is the best value for the consumer and has great installation features and a easy, solid, no-frills warranty to sell for the contractor.

Joe Wameling, roofer

Owens Corning Duration with that beautiful sure nail strip!!

The Malarkey line is really good as well. Especially since they redesigned the Highlander which had terrible problems. GAF use to be good but now there shingles look terrible and have streaking lines and color patches that look terrible! They widened the nail zone but that didn’t widen the tru or common bond area. In the NW. IKO and Tamko are bottom of the barrel. I have seen a good change in the Atlas line lately…

Garris Spaccamonti, roofer

GAF Timberline/HD shingles

It will be a slugfest in here. However, GAF Timberline/HD shingles. 200 Consecutive roofs, 3 cities, 1 issue. And the house saw wind 1 day after install. 5/12, too cold for strips to seal. No complaints here. Before, we used 100% CertainTeed for 300+. No issues.

J.t. Granberry, Restoration Resourcing, LLC

I really like Owens Corning Duration for regular asphalt

For higher end Berkshire. Grand manor. Presidentials.But I would really like to get my hands on malarkey. Haven’t had them NEPA

Richie Antonio, roofer

Malarkey Vista, in particular

Malarkey Vista, in particular. We have used most major major manufactures through the years (OC Duration would be my 2nd pick) but stone coated steel is where it’s at!

Kevin Phillips, roofer

A very unscientific flamethrower video for fun (Euroshield vs F-Wave)

Having had the chance to talk to Euroshield and F-wave recently, I think there are great parts about both shingles as they are both synthetic and class-4 hail resistant (the strongest hail qualification.)

Future Award: F-Wave Plastic Shingle

  • Has a higher fire rating
  • Very clean and slim profile
  • Appears more like normal asphalt shingles
  • Made of a large percentage of recycled plastic.
  • Cons: They sell it like it’s self-healing with heat, but it appears that’s not likely under normal sun conditions. (They demonstrate it with a heat gun.)
  • Cons: Unconfirmed but some have stated that the color fades.

Future Award: Euroshield Rubber Shingle

  • From our very unscientific tests, seems to stand up to most extreme damage better
  • Has a really good looking aesthetic as well.
  • More likely to last a long, long time than almost any other shingle.
  • Cons: Very strong rubber smell if you’re ever storing inside.

Factor in cost: Pricing of the best roofing shingles

The prices for these shingles are not directly listed on the manufacturer’s websites. The price often depends on the specific product, location, and the cost of installation.

How the main brands compare on price:

  • Malarkey: usually priced as a premium shingle.
  • Atlas Pinnacle, GAF Timberline and Owens Corning Duration: mainstream architectural shingles, typically in a similar price range to each other.
  • TAMKO and IKO: often the budget choice.

Material prices change with the market and your region, so check current pricing with your local supplier or ask a contractor for a quote. For a breakdown of what goes into a roof, see our roofing basics guide.

For synthetic options like F-Wave plastic shingles and Euroshield rubber shingles, they are generally more expensive than traditional asphalt shingles. Again, prices can vary significantly depending on the specific product and installation costs, so it’s best to get a quote from a local contractor for the most accurate pricing.

Roofers – what’s your favorite shingle?

If you have the insider view on what shingles, answer these questions in the comments:

  • What shingles hold up the best under normal conditions?
  • What shingles look the best from the street?
  • What shingles resist storms the best?

Comment below on this post, and we’ll include a highlight from your share in the article, and link back to your company website if you offer value!

Own a roofing company? See how Hook helps roofers get more calls with roofing marketing.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best roofing shingle brand?

There is no single winner. Among the roofers we surveyed, Malarkey was picked most often, followed by Atlas Pinnacle, Owens Corning Duration and GAF Timberline. The best choice depends on your climate, budget and the warranty your installer offers.

Are synthetic shingles better than asphalt?

Synthetic shingles like Euroshield rubber and F-Wave plastic can offer strong impact resistance, including Class 4 hail ratings, but they generally cost more than asphalt and fewer installers carry them.

Is GAF or Owens Corning better?

Both are large, well-known brands with popular architectural lines (GAF Timberline and Owens Corning Duration). Roofers in our survey were split, so compare warranties and local installer experience.

Learn How To Do Google Local Service Ads Yourself (Free DIY Course)

Want to know how to start getting Local Service Ads leads on your own?

🎥 3 original videos designed to help you get started on LSA Ads.

🔥 Get the ‘Google Guaranteed’ badge to use in other marketing as well.

📈 Only pay per lead, and start getting more leads soon!

Is there you or someone on your team that would like to take it? Enter their info (or yours) below!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Stop wasting your time

Work with a marketing agency that's going to get you what you actually care about, dominate your market, and make you MONEY 💰

Book an Intro Call