It’s summer, the sun is scorching, and you’re looking for a hero to save you from the heat. Who’s going to come to the rescue? Amana and Carrier, two titans of the air conditioning industry, are stepping into the ring. Let’s see who packs the most punch.

The Amana Advantage

First off, we’ve got Amana, the seasoned veteran, cooling homes since 1954. Amana’s air conditioners are like the heavyweights of the HVAC world, with an impressive range of models with SEER ratings from 13 all the way up to 24.5. That’s enough to turn your home into a veritable Arctic paradise!​¹​.

Amana units are like the silent assassins of the heat, boasting a quiet operation around 70.3 decibels. They’re built to last with robust bodies and a powder finish on the unit chassis, ready to take a beating from whatever Mother Nature throws their way. However, they do have a soft spot – a lack of insulation and protective grills around the compressor, which can lead to breakdowns​¹​.

But wait, there’s more! Amana isn’t just about brawn, it’s about brains too. Features like the Copeland High-Efficiency Scroll Compressor and the CoreSense Diagnostics system not only make these units efficient, but also smart at detecting mechanical issues before they become big problems​¹​.

What about the price tag, you ask? While the units themselves are reasonably priced, Amana is known for high installation costs. But once you get past that initial investment, customers have been more than pleased with their cooling companion​¹​.

Amana really shines when it comes to warranties, offering a limited lifetime replacement warranty and a 10-year parts warranty. But make sure to register your equipment within 60 days or else your warranty will only last for five years after installation​¹​.

The Carrier Conquest

On the other side of the ring, we’ve got Carrier, an innovator that’s been pushing the boundaries of cool since Willis Carrier invented the modern air conditioner in 1902. They offer a range of models with SEER ratings up to 21, which are equipped with a state-of-the-art “Infinity Control” system for regulating temperature and humidity levels​²​.

Carrier’s units are also known for their quiet operation, and while they’re made to last, they can be susceptible to breakdowns due to lack of protective grills around the compressor, a common point of contention for users​³​.

When it comes to cost, Carrier air conditioners can also be a significant investment, but you’re paying for quality and longevity. And unlike Amana, Carrier has its own training and certification programs, ensuring that the technicians who install your unit know exactly what they’re doing​⁴​.

In the warranty department, Carrier offers a 10-year parts limited warranty as long as you register your product within 90 days of installation​⁵​.

The Final Verdict for Homeowners

Both Amana and Carrier offer robust, high-performing air conditioners that could be the perfect solution to your summer heat problems. The right choice for you will depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences.

Alright, HVAC enthusiasts, let’s break it down! You’ve been following my deep dive into the world of Amana and Carrier air conditioners, and I know you’re all waiting for that verdict. So, let’s get to it, shall we?

drum roll

🏠 For Homeowners:

Alright, homeowners, let’s talk comfort, cost, and coolness factor. In the blue corner, we have Amana. Their units are power-packed with features that’ll leave you feeling cool and breezy even on the hottest summer days. The cherry on top? They’re budget-friendly! But watch out for those installation costs. They can be a bit of a surprise. And if you’re someone who likes your peace and quiet, Amana’s units may not be the quietest on the block.

In the red corner, we have Carrier. This industry heavyweight has been keeping homes cool for over a century. They’re reliable, they’re durable, and they hum along quieter than a cat on a hot tin roof. They might cost a bit more upfront, but with their energy efficiency, they’ll save you some pretty pennies in the long run.

So who wins the homeowner heavyweight title? It’s a close call, but I’m going to have to give it to Carrier for their reliability, quiet operation, and energy efficiency.

Who’s a better partner for Contractors: Amana or Carrier?

• Amana air conditioning systems are known for their impressive features and excellent warranties. They offer a limited lifetime replacement warranty for models with ratings of 16 SEER and higher, and a 10-year parts warranty for all models. However, models with SEER ratings under 16 only have 10-year compressor coverage​¹​.
• Amana’s units are efficient, affordable, and robust, and the top models have high SEER ratings, which make them more energy-efficient and can help to reduce energy bills. However, these units lack insulation or protective grills around the compressor, which may result in damage or breakdowns. Despite this, Amana’s customer service ratings are high, and the units are known to last longer than some of their competitors​¹​.
• The starting cost of a 13-14 SEER model is around $1,290 for the unit alone, but it totals around $3,510 with installation. The top-tier model with a 24.5 SEER rating costs around $2,850 for the unit alone and would cost around $6,800 with installation. It is important to note that Amana is infamous for high installation costs​¹​.
• Amana and Goodman do not have their own training or certification program. So it’s advisable to find highly-rated installers who have advanced certifications and experience with Amana products. Goodman recommends that customers and buyers look for technicians with the NATE Certification, which stands for North American Technician Excellence​¹​.

Amana is known for providing powerful central air conditioning units that are efficient and affordable.

They offer models with SEER ratings ranging from 13 to 24.5. Their units have impressive features like the Copeland High-Efficiency Scroll Compressor, CoreSense Diagnostics system, and ComfortNet technology system. Despite their affordability, they are also known for high installation costs. Amana has an excellent warranty coverage, with a limited lifetime replacement warranty for models with SEER ratings of 16 and above. Their customer service ratings are high, and their units are praised for their longevity​¹​.

Carrier is very reputable and has been around a long time

On the other hand, Carrier is a reputable brand that has been in the air conditioning industry since 1902. They offer a range of units with SEER ratings from 13 to 21. Their units are praised for their reliability, durability, and quiet operation. Carrier also offers great warranty coverage and their customer service ratings are high​²​.

🛠️ For Contractors:

Alright, my contractor comrades, let’s talk shop. You want a product that’s reliable, has solid warranty coverage, and gives you less headache in the field. Amana has some strong points, particularly their solid warranty. But they don’t have a dedicated training or certification program, which can put you at a disadvantage.

Carrier, on the other hand, has a long-standing reputation in the industry. While their units might be a bit more complex to install, their reliability and durability mean you won’t be getting call-backs for breakdowns any time soon.

In this face-off, Carrier takes the contractor crown. Their reputation, reliability, and durability make them a strong ally for any HVAC contractor out there.

So there you have it folks! Whether you’re a homeowner or contractor, Carrier seems to have the edge. But remember, every situation is unique. So do your homework, consider your specific needs, and make the best choice for YOU!

Stay cool, my friends! 😎