The Catch-All Roofing System vs. Tarps: Pro’s + Con’s

How do you blend in with every other roofer to the neighbors? Use traditional tarps. Beyond just keeping a job site clean and making it grab neighbors attention – the system use…

Estimated Read Time:  7 minutes


How do you blend in with every other roofer to the neighbors?

Use traditional tarps.

Beyond just keeping a job site clean and making it grab neighbors attention – the system use around a home during a roof install says a lot about your company (and can be a line item when charging an insurance company!)

Traditionally, tarps have been the go-to solution, but with innovations like the Catch-All Roofing System, there are now alternative options. This blog post will delve into a detailed comparison between the Catch-All Roofing System and traditional tarps, highlighting the benefits and drawbacks of each to help you decide which is best for your roofing projects.

Enhanced Protection using the Catch-all system vs. Tarps

Catch-All Roofing System:

  • Comprehensive Coverage: The Catch-All system is designed to offer extensive protection, covering landscaping, siding, and windows more effectively than tarps.
  • Durability: Made from high-quality materials, the Catch-All system is less prone to tearing and can withstand harsh weather conditions, providing consistent protection throughout the project.

Traditional Tarps:

  • Basic Coverage: While tarps can cover large areas, they often leave gaps and may not fit snugly around intricate landscaping or architectural features.
  • Vulnerability: Tarps are susceptible to tears and punctures, which can compromise the protection they offer and require frequent adjustments or replacements.

Professional Appearance

Catch-All Roofing System:

  • Organized Look: The system creates a neat and professional appearance, showcasing your commitment to quality and care.
  • Customer Confidence: A well-organized job site can enhance customer satisfaction and trust, potentially leading to more referrals and repeat business.

Traditional Tarps:

  • Messy Aesthetic: Tarps can look untidy, especially if they are not secured properly. This can create a negative impression on clients and passersby.
  • Perception of Carelessness: An unkempt job site may be perceived as a lack of attention to detail, affecting your reputation.

Time Efficiency

Catch-All Roofing System:

  • Quick Setup and Removal: The system is designed for fast installation and dismantling, saving valuable time on the job.
  • Streamlined Workflow: Reduced setup and cleanup times allow your team to focus more on the actual roofing work, increasing overall productivity.

Traditional Tarps:

  • Labor-Intensive: Setting up tarps can be time-consuming and often requires multiple adjustments to ensure proper coverage.
  • Extended Cleanup: Post-job cleanup can take longer as tarps may not contain debris as effectively, leading to more time spent tidying up.

Safety Improvements

Catch-All Roofing System:

  • Slip-Resistant: The system helps prevent slips, trips, and falls by providing a secure surface and reducing obstacles on the ground.
  • Fewer Hazards: By containing debris and protecting the surroundings, the Catch-All system reduces potential hazards for both workers and homeowners.

Traditional Tarps:

  • Potential Hazards: Loose or improperly secured tarps can create tripping hazards and increase the risk of accidents.
  • Frequent Adjustments: Constantly adjusting tarps can be hazardous for workers, especially on steep or uneven surfaces.

Debris Management

Catch-All Roofing System:

  • Efficient Containment: The system is designed to catch and contain debris, making cleanup quick and easy.
  • Less Mess: By effectively managing debris, the Catch-All system keeps the job site cleaner, reducing the risk of damage to the property.

Traditional Tarps:

  • Debris Spillage: Tarps can struggle to contain all debris, leading to a messier job site and more extensive cleanup.
  • Property Damage: Falling debris that escapes the tarp’s coverage can damage landscaping and other property features.

Cost Considerations

Catch-All Roofing System:

  • Initial Investment: The upfront cost of the Catch-All system can be higher, but the long-term benefits often justify the expense.
  • Return on Investment: Increased efficiency, protection, and customer satisfaction can lead to higher profitability and growth.

Traditional Tarps:

  • Lower Initial Cost: Tarps are generally cheaper to purchase initially, making them a more budget-friendly option for smaller companies.
  • Frequent Replacements: Due to their susceptibility to damage, tarps may need to be replaced more often, potentially increasing long-term costs.

Recommended Videos about The Catch-all Roofing system

This video by Roofing Insights provides a comprehensive review of the Catch-All system, discussing its features, benefits, and how it compares to traditional tarps in real-world scenarios.

YouTube video

This insightful video from our client G and Bros Roofing explains why they switched from using tarps to the Catch-All system, highlighting the advantages in terms of protection, efficiency, and customer satisfaction.

YouTube video


Setting Up Your New Catch-All System: A Step-by-Step Guide

At Hook Agency, we understand the importance of efficient and professional job site management. The Catch-All system is a game-changer in this regard, offering unparalleled protection for properties during roofing projects. Here’s a comprehensive guide on how to set up your new Catch-All system.

YouTube video

1. Gutter Inserts

The first step is to install the gutter inserts, which protect the gutters from debris and prevent damage from ladders.

  • Installing Gutter Inserts:
    • Start at one end of the gutter.
    • Tilt the insert 90 degrees, slide it into the gutter, and then rotate it into position.
    • Ensure the gutter hangers are positioned between the collection cups.
    • Slide the insert left or right as needed to accommodate the hangers.
    • Repeat this process for additional gutter inserts, overlapping slightly between pieces to cover the entire length of the gutter.

2. Chute Nets

Next, set up the chute nets, which are designed to guide light debris away from the home and onto the ground nets.

  • Attaching the Chute Nets:
    • Lay out the chute net on the ground.
    • Starting at one end, attach the net to the carabiner at the top of the support pole.
    • Lean the pole against the house at about a 60-degree angle.
    • Work your way along, attaching the other poles to the net and leaning them against the house as well.
    • Use two poles for each side and one pole for the middle. Ensure the two outer poles lean away from the center.

3. Ground Protection

The ground nets are designed to handle heavy loads, providing robust protection over solid surfaces like grass or concrete.

  • Setting Up Ground Protection:
    • Place the ground nets in high-traffic areas where the majority of debris will collect.
    • Lay out the nets at the base of the chute nets, ensuring about a one-foot overlap on each side.
    • Use landscape nets to cover any low-impact areas, such as gable ends.

4. Cleanup

Once the roofing work is complete, cleanup will be straightforward and efficient.

  • Cleanup Process:
    • Start from the top and work your way down.
    • Rotate the gutter inserts up and out of the gutter, emptying them onto the ground nets.
    • Shake off any remaining debris from the chute nets onto the ground nets.
    • Using the reinforced handles, fold the debris into the middle of the ground net and then carry it to your dump trailer.

With the Catch-All system, protecting the job site and ensuring a thorough cleanup has never been easier. For more information and detailed instructions, visit The Catch-All.

Happy roofing!

Catch-all vs. Tarps

When it comes to choosing between the Catch-All Roofing System and traditional tarps, the decision ultimately depends on your specific needs and priorities. The Catch-All system offers superior protection, a professional appearance, time efficiency, improved safety, and better debris management, making it a strong contender for modern roofing projects. On the other hand, traditional tarps remain a viable option for those with budget constraints or simpler projects.

At Hook Agency, we’re dedicated to helping roofing professionals make informed decisions that enhance their business operations. If you’re considering upgrading to the Catch-All system or have questions about how it can benefit your projects, feel free to reach out. We’re here to support your growth and success in the roofing industry.

Are You a Home Service Business Who Wants to Increase Your Qualified Leads?

Contact Us Now

 100+ 5-Stars



The Roofing Academy