Owens Corning vs GAF: The Ultimate Shingle Showdown

Well hello there, roofing enthusiasts and decision-dilemma homeowners! Today we’re diving into the fiery debate of the century: Owens Corning vs GAF. Which shingle brand will emerge victorious and claim the roofing…

Estimated Read Time:  6 minutes


Owens Corning vs. GAF

Well hello there, roofing enthusiasts and decision-dilemma homeowners! Today we’re diving into the fiery debate of the century: Owens Corning vs GAF. Which shingle brand will emerge victorious and claim the roofing crown? By the end of this explosive article, you’ll be armed with the knowledge to make the best decision for your home and your wallet.

YouTube video

Round One: Owens Corning – The Pros

First up, let’s talk about Owens Corning. If we’re talking durability, this brand’s got it in spades. Its patented SureNail Technology offers superior wind resistance, making it perfect for those storm-prone regions. Not to mention, their broad range of color options and styles will leave your neighbors green with envy.

Owens Corning – The Cons

But it’s not all sunshine and rainbows with Owens Corning. Be prepared to dig a little deeper into your pockets, as these shingles generally command a higher price point. Also, despite their durability, some homeowners have reported granule loss over time, which could affect the shingle’s longevity and visual appeal.

A more in-depth review of Owens Corning shingles:

When it comes to roofing, Owens Corning is a name that frequently comes up. Renowned for their quality and durability, these shingles have become a favorite among homeowners and contractors. In this review, we’ll dig deep into the specifics of Owens Corning shingles.


Owens Corning shingles are known for their strong durability. They feature the brand’s SureNail Technology, a unique design that provides excellent grip and wind resistance. However, it’s worth noting that some users have reported granule loss over time, which might affect the shingle’s longevity.

Design and Aesthetics

One of the stand-out features of Owens Corning shingles is the wide variety of styles and colors they offer. Whether you’re looking for vibrant hues or deep, bold tones, Owens Corning seems to have an option for everyone. However, the large selection can also be overwhelming for some homeowners.

Energy Efficiency

Owens Corning shingles offer potential energy-saving benefits, especially with their cool roof colors designed to reflect solar energy. This can contribute to a cooler home and lower energy bills, although the efficiency can vary depending on the specific product and your local climate.


Owens Corning provides comprehensive warranties for their shingles, which include limited lifetime warranties and options for system protection warranties. This gives homeowners peace of mind, but it’s important to remember that warranties often have specific requirements and limitations, so read the fine print.


Contractors often appreciate the ease of installation with Owens Corning shingles. The SureNail strip offers a clear nailing zone, reducing the risk of improper nail placement. However, less experienced DIY homeowners might find the installation process more challenging.


Let’s talk about the price. Owens Corning shingles tend to be on the higher end of the price spectrum. While you’re getting a high-quality product, the cost might be a barrier for some homeowners, especially those on a tighter budget.

In conclusion, Owens Corning shingles are a solid option for homeowners looking for durability, variety, and potential energy efficiency. However, the higher price and potential for granule loss are factors to consider. We recommend Owens Corning for homeowners who are ready to make a long-term investment in their roof and value the wide selection of design options.

Owens Corning vs. GAF

Round Two: GAF – The Pros

Now, onto the GAF corner. GAF shingles boast Advanced Protection Technology, ensuring top-notch performance and long-term durability. Plus, GAF’s cost-effectiveness will keep your budget happy without compromising on quality.

GAF – The Cons

The downside? GAF’s color and style options may not be as extensive as Owens Corning. So if you’re someone who values aesthetics as much as performance, this might be a slight drawback. Moreover, there have been some reports of early wear and tear, which is definitely a factor to consider.

GAF Shingles: An In-Depth Review

GAF, another heavyweight in the roofing industry, has been providing quality shingles for homes across America for decades. Let’s take a closer look at what GAF shingles have to offer, and weigh up their strengths and potential downsides.


GAF shingles come with Advanced Protection Technology, which promises excellent performance and long-term durability. However, some homeowners have reported early wear and tear, suggesting that the actual lifespan of these shingles may vary.

Design and Aesthetics

While GAF offers a range of styles and colors, their selection might not be as extensive as some other brands, such as Owens Corning. Nevertheless, their designs are modern and attractive, and they should be able to satisfy most homeowners’ aesthetic preferences.

Energy Efficiency

Some GAF shingles are designed with energy efficiency in mind, and their Cool Series shingles reflect sunlight to reduce attic heat build-up and save energy. But like with any energy efficiency claim, actual savings can depend on many factors, such as local climate and home insulation.


GAF provides strong warranty options, including a limited lifetime warranty for many of their shingles. This is a significant advantage for homeowners seeking peace of mind. However, as with any warranty, it’s crucial to understand what is and isn’t covered and under what conditions the warranty applies.


For contractors, GAF shingles are often praised for their ease of installation. They feature a clear nailing zone, reducing the risk of installation errors. For DIY homeowners, however, the installation might pose a challenge, as with any roofing project.


GAF shingles are generally more budget-friendly compared to some other brands, making them a popular choice for homeowners working within a specific budget. However, lower cost can sometimes mean compromises in certain areas, such as the range of designs or potential longevity.

In summary, GAF shingles offer reliable performance, ease of installation, and are cost-effective, making them a strong contender in the roofing market. However, the reports of early wear and tear and the somewhat limited design options are potential considerations. We recommend GAF for homeowners seeking a balance between cost and quality, and for those who are not overly concerned with having an extensive range of design choices.

The Verdict

So, who is the champion in the Owens Corning vs GAF showdown? Drumroll, please… For homeowners, we’re giving the crown to Owens Corning! Yes, they may be a tad pricier, but the superior durability and extensive color options make it a worthy investment for your dream home.

Now, for contractors, the story is a bit different. We recommend GAF. Their cost-effectiveness and reliable performance make them a fantastic choice for contractors who are constantly juggling quality and cost.

And there you have it, folks! The ultimate shingle showdown has concluded. Remember, the best shingle for you will ultimately depend on your specific needs and circumstances. But armed with this knowledge, you are now a step closer to making a well-informed decision. Until next time, stay shingle-savvy!

Are You a Home Service Business Who Wants to Increase Your Qualified Leads?

Contact Us Now

 100+ 5-Stars



The Roofing Academy